/r/ButtSharpies - top ten submissions for each month of 2025
sfw subreddits
|
nsfw subreddits
| <<
ButtSharpies 2024
2025, February
1525 And they said it couldn’t be done.. 25 ??
1266 I can’t believe 12 fit!
1052 Daddy ????????
879 11 this time. Might have to buy some more
811 Need nasty ideas!
622 It may only be one, butt that just means I can’...
607 You guys motivated me to get to two! [oc]
589 Three! Thanks for the tips :) [oc]
583 Up to four medium ones, butt ran out of actual ...
524 We did 9:)
2025, January
3187 23 and me…
2544 [OC] I’m new to this, be gentle please ?
2530 [self] new year new personal sharpie record ?
2448 21! Finally beat my own record ?
2319 [OC] Here is the much requested video
1990 Managed 7 in the butthole
1816 [OC] Couldn’t help coming back for more ?
1795 throwback to my first time ever trying buttshar...
1659 [OC] This big sharpie felt so good in my whore ...
1373 (OC) 1st time, got 7 in.?
![You guys motivated me to get to two! [oc]](https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/xSb11FoKyjYyW15dBwLEmCIOmQ-W3HNMie65hVYHRQA.jpg "607 - You guys motivated me to get to two! [oc]")
![Three! Thanks for the tips :) [oc]](https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/ySdxp7L0mH5OqQNnHmPOa_uS-Lrespd1f52TMKjNLnw.jpg "589 - Three! Thanks for the tips :) [oc]")
![[OC] I’m new to this, be gentle please ?](https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/ToH575QYTKO0qGihTWCuQPnWC1nNmziycQpYG91L3XU.jpg "2544 - [OC] I’m new to this, be gentle please ?")
![[self] new year new personal sharpie record ?](https://a.thumbs.redditmedia.com/E_uotF9uXlgbBnXQTI9H-JVeIhw0Vyqm8W_2zizp1c8.jpg "2530 - [self] new year new personal sharpie record ?")
![[OC] Here is the much requested video](https://a.thumbs.redditmedia.com/3nriW7mMpCRNH5I2CbaZ3hsRd5iPtG4N_xiq5gMR7T4.jpg "2319 - [OC] Here is the much requested video")
![[OC] Couldn’t help coming back for more ?](https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/fyM5akCVp6kykniFfBbPHVTNCRlqF8DwTMoOKgAyG8g.jpg "1816 - [OC] Couldn’t help coming back for more ?")
![[OC] This big sharpie felt so good in my whore ...](https://b.thumbs.redditmedia.com/-4ogAbuFme7Dp_g13T-XaIuYv7EOcvUsTf4c9kuU87E.jpg "1659 - [OC] This big sharpie felt so good in my whore ass ?")
